Chemist + Druggist is part of Informa PLC


This site is operated by a business or businesses owned by Informa PLC and all copyright resides with them. Informa PLC’s registered office is 5 Howick Place, London SW1P 1WG. Registered in England and Wales. Number 8860726.


This copy is for your personal, non-commercial use. Please do not redistribute without permission.

Printed By

UsernamePublicRestriction

Judge dismisses Pharmacy2U demand for all NPA members' contact details

A High Court judge has today dismissed Pharmacy2U’s request for the contact details of every member of the NPA.

Handing down her judgment this morning (December 14) – which C+D attended – Master Julia Clark said Pharmacy2U had “fallen far short of showing” that the court should order the National Pharmacy Association (NPA) to hand over names, addresses and contact details of its members.

Pharmacy2U alleged that a NPA leaflet and poster (see below) distributed to members from November 2017 onwards had damaged the company’s reputation.

After the NPA refused to hand over these personal details, Pharmacy2U sought permission from the High Court to directly contact the 3,202 pharmacies who had been sent the materials.

Pharmacy2U intended to write to each member informing them that the materials "constitute trademark infringement", asking them not to publish the material further, and destroy all copies in their possession, the court explained.

Assessing the extent of the “damage”

While the online pharmacy business accepted that the statements used in the NPA materials were true, it claimed the leaflet’s “primary purpose is to disparage the services offered by Pharmacy2U by making reference to historic difficulties that the company experienced and using these to unfairly promote the services of the NPA’s members above those of Pharmacy2U”, according to the court documents.

“In short, the [leaflet] is nothing more than an attempt to rubbish the value of Pharmacy2U’s brand and divert business away from Pharmacy2U to NPA members,” the company said.

Pharmacy2U claimed it needed the names and contact details of thousands of pharmacies “to enable [it] to understand the extent of the damage that it had been exposed to” and “enable it to contact those individuals, with a view to trying to address the ongoing harm being caused to Pharmacy2U”.

In her judgment, Master Clark said the contact details of the NPA members are “not necessary for the purpose of Pharmacy2U understanding the extent of the damage to which it has been exposed”, and ruled the company’s request was not “necessary or desirable”.

Accusing pharmacies of wrongdoing

“Pharmacy2U is not seeking to write to [NPA] members simply to set the record straight,” Master Clark added.

In writing to each member, Pharmacy2U was planning to allege that pharmacies which had displayed the materials were “a wrongdoer, against whom a claim could be brought”, she said.

“To bring a claim against each [NPA member] for each (minor) act of infringement would, in my judgment, be disproportionate,” she added.

NPA members “were not responsible for the wording of the [marketing materials] and have no direct knowledge of its truth or falsity”, she stressed.

“There is a serious risk, therefore, that Pharmacy2U will be able to ‘pick off’ the individual members,” she added, rather than target the NPA as an organisation.

NPA: “Unreasonable” attempt to intimidate pharmacists

Commenting on the judgment, the NPA said: “The court has seen this for what it is, a completely unjustified and unreasonable attempt to obtain details of our members in order to intimidate them. 

“Online pharmacies have a place within the health sector and we have a significant number within our membership, but all pharmacies must behave appropriately irrespective of their business model,” it added.

C+D has contacted Pharmacy2U for comment.

See the NPA leaflet and poster in full.

What do you make of the High Court judgment?

Related Content

Topics



Pharmacist Managers - Recruiting Now !
East London, Essex and Luton
£40,000 - £50,000 per year

Apply Now
UsernamePublicRestriction

Register

CD005667

Ask The Analyst

Please Note: You can also Click below Link for Ask the Analyst
Ask The Analyst

Thank you for submitting your question. We will respond to you within 2 business days. my@email.address.

All fields are required.

Please make sure all fields are completed.

Please make sure you have filled out all fields

Please make sure you have filled out all fields

Please enter a valid e-mail address

Please enter a valid Phone Number

Ask your question to our analysts

Cancel