Chemist & Druggist is part of the Informa Tech Division of Informa PLC

This site is operated by a business or businesses owned by Informa PLC and all copyright resides with them. Informa PLC’s registered office is 5 Howick Place, London SW1P 1WG. Registered in England and Wales. Number 8860726.

This copy is for your personal, non-commercial use. Please do not redistribute without permission. Printed by #UserName#, #Company_Name#

Printed By


Pharmacist spends month securing medicine for terminally ill patients

A pharmacist has told C+D of a month-long ordeal to secure pain relief medication for terminally ill patients – after the manufacturer’s reduced wholesaler model disrupted supply.

Last month, Sakthivel Thiagarajan, superintendent of Anji’s Pharmacy in Leyton, London, attempted to source several brand-specific medicines manufactured by Napp Pharmaceuticals, to help patients suffering from respiratory diseases and terminal illness, he told C+D last week (May 4).

On March 24, Numark announced that Napp Pharmaceuticals would move to a reduced wholesaler model from April 1, partnering with Phoenix and AAH, and dropping Alliance Healthcare as a supplier.

The list of medicines that can now only be ordered via Phoenix or AAH includes Palladone, Sevredol and Butec patches – all of which can be used for pain relief in terminally ill patients.

When Mr Thiagarajan attempted to order several medicines on the list from Phoenix, he was told that he would need to pay a £138 per month membership fee to Numark, and spend a minimum of £5,000 with them, he claimed.

This is “absolutely impossible” for a pharmacy that only needs to make a few small orders a month, he told C+D.

Similarly, when his team attempted to source the medicines from AAH, they were told they would need to spend a minimum of £2,500 a month or face a surcharge between £300-500, he claimed.

Both wholesalers denied having minimum spend requirements when contacted by C+D.

A spokesperson for Phoenix UK said: “It is not and never has been, a policy of Phoenix to restrict the sale of drugs through requesting account upgrades.”

While AAH said: “AAH does not apply a minimum spend target for community pharmacy customers, after pledging our support to independent contractors in December and taking the decision not to add any surcharges to their orders, for any reason.”

Read more of the wholesalers’ responses below.

“Issues during transition to reduced wholesaler model”

An email from a Napp Pharmaceuticals representative, seen by C+D, explained that there had been “some issues with the TPOS system that automatically re-routes orders placed with Alliance to your second line wholesaler” during the company’s “transition period” to a “reduced wholesaler model”.

They said the issue had now been resolved, and orders made via Alliance would automatically be delivered by an alternative wholesaler.

Mr Thiagarajan confirmed that he was able to access the medicines via Alliance Healthcare, his original wholesaler, late last week.

“I am so disappointed with Napp Pharmaceuticals,” he said. “We should be helping patients – especially if they are in a difficult situation – but rather than doing the things that we are here to do, we are wasting our time,” Mr Thiagarajan added.

The manufacturer should have been aware of the important use of its medicines before potentially disrupting access to them, and “rather than leaving us to sort it out”, Mr Thiagarajan added.

All medicines “should be readily available” to pharmacies, he stressed.

A Napp Pharmaceuticals spokesperson told C+D: “We were made aware of this regrettable situation in April and immediately investigated. The wholesalers we work with to distribute our medicines have confirmed that the issue has been rectified and that steps have been put in place to avoid a repeat of the situation.

“Napp believes that patient access to our medicines is of the utmost importance. We can confirm that our medicines can be purchased by pharmacies without restriction or a need to meet criteria.”

Wholesalers “very concerned”

The spokesperson for Phoenix added: “We are very concerned to hear that the pharmacist and subsequently patient has had difficulties obtaining the medicines they need. We do our best every day to protect our nation’s health and meet both our customers’ and their patients’ needs.  

“We are committed to doing our utmost to ensure fluid access to supply of medicines, we are flexible in our approach and aim to be as responsive as possible. We would like the opportunity to review this particular situation and pick up a conversation with the pharmacist in question about how we can support future supply.”

And AAH added: “Our priority is to make it as easy as possible for our customers to do business with us and ensure they’re able to access the medicines they need, when they need them.”

Have you been unable to access any medicines because of minimum spend requirements?

Related Content


Pre-reg Trainee

Tonbridge, Kent

 Salary: £22,000

Apply Now



Ask The Analyst

Please Note: You can also Click below Link for Ask the Analyst
Ask The Analyst

Thank you for submitting your question. We will respond to you within 2 business days. my@email.address.

All fields are required.

Please make sure all fields are completed.

Please make sure you have filled out all fields

Please make sure you have filled out all fields

Please enter a valid e-mail address

Please enter a valid Phone Number

Ask your question to our analysts