‘If you are a superintendent on your summer holidays...’

"Because of the decision, the reprimands were held to be unsafe, and the whole of the disciplinary committee’s decision was overturned..."

Striped beach umbrella on the beach.
"It is true that certain duties of the superintendent cannot be delegated"

At this time of year, many people are heading off to their summer holidays. That includes superintendent pharmacists. I claim some credit for the fact that they can do so.

As a newly qualified solicitor when the pharmacy regulator was the Pharmaceutical Society of Great Britain (long before it was Royal), I dealt with many disciplinary cases before its disciplinary committee.

Read more: Bolt rapped by ASA over latest Facebook weight-loss ads

Whenever something went wrong at a pharmacy owned by a company, it was the Pharmaceutical Society’s standard practice to bring both the company and the superintendent pharmacist before the disciplinary. In those days, typical disciplinary committee cases involved breaches of professional advertising rules.

It will probably seem strange to many readers that there were restrictions on advertising. Indeed, all the professions, including my own, placed restrictions on advertising. The Pharmaceutical Society had published guidance. For example, there was a limit on the number of columns of text and the word “chemist” could not appear more than four times in the feature. It all seems faintly ridiculous now, but it was treated very seriously at the time.

Holiday

It was not unusual for pharmacies to pay to appear in an advertising feature of a local newspaper but whatever instructions had been given to the newspaper reporters about what they could or could not write, it was often the case that reporters would ignore those instructions.

Lewis & Jeffreys Limited had opened a pharmacy in Potters Bar and the company wanted to promote the opening in an advertising feature that appeared in the Barnet Press and the Potters Bar Press in June 1981.

Read more: ASA issues multiple rulings against Juniper for promoting POMs

The advertising feature breached the Pharmaceutical Society’s guidance. The superintendent pharmacist, Mr Berg, had been involved in the advertising feature, but had gone on holiday before the final proof of the advertising feature was available, leaving Mr Brandon, a pharmacist who was in control of the pharmacy in his absence, to deal with the journalist who was writing the feature.

The Pharmaceutical Society brought a disciplinary committee case against the company, the superintendent and Mr Brandon. The disciplinary committee, chaired by a retired Old Bailey judge, decided that none of the parties had done enough to prevent the offending advertisement from appearing in the local papers. All three were found guilty of misconduct and were reprimanded (the most severe sanction before striking off).

Guilty?

Even though the superintendent pharmacist had responsibility for legal and professional compliance by the company, it seemed wrong that the superintendent should be treated as automatically guilty of misconduct unless he had done something wrong or failed to do something he should have. I was instructed to apply to the High Court for judicial review of the disciplinary committee’s decision.

Read more: Ads regulator raps Phlo over Morrisons weight loss ad

This was my first judicial review case. It was heard by Mr Justice Woolf who later became one of the country’s most senior judges. It was not in dispute that the company, Mr Berg and Mr Brandon were all responsible for the offending advertisement. The judge noted that Mr Berg, the superintendent, had gone on holiday before the final draft of the advertisement was available. The judge said:

“… it is difficult … to see how Mr Berg could be criticised in a manner which would entitle him to be regarded as someone who had been guilty of misconduct who rendered himself liable to be removed from the register. It is true that certain duties of the superintendent cannot be delegated. However, when you bear in mind that a company as large as Boots only has one superintendent pharmacist, it cannot be the intention that superintendents should not use other pharmacists to perform certain of their functions. … He was presumably entitled to go on holiday and could not be blamed for what happened while he was away …”.

Delegate

Because of the decision concerning Mr Berg, the reprimands of the company and Mr Brandon were held to be unsafe and the whole of the disciplinary committee’s decision was overturned.

The General Pharmaceutical Council has recently consulted on draft Standards for Superintendent Pharmacists. The draft Standards expressly recognise that superintendents can delegate so long as they do so responsibly. I expect that the final version of the Standards will be in place very soon and that they will confirm that superintendent pharmacists can delegate responsibly.

So, if you are a superintendent pharmacist and about to head off on your summer holidays, you’re welcome!

David Reissner is chair of the Pharmacy Law & Ethics Association

Latest from Opinion

More from Analysis