It’s a busy day in the pharmacy and you’ve got a thumping headache, a runny nose and a sore throat. You’re pretty sure it’s just the nasty cold you’ve been advising patients about for the past week. But even so, you feel terrible.
Would you decide you’ve got nothing more than the sniffles and grab the over-the-counter remedy you’ve been recommending to patients with the same cold? Or visit another pharmacy or GP to get a second opinion?
Chances are that you’d do the former. After all, pharmacists spend much of their working lives advising patients on how to treat their minor illnesses, so it stands to reason that they feel they are justified to follow their own advice.
But at what stage do you have to swallow professional pride and ask for help from a fellow healthcare professional, rather than rigidly sticking to your own treatment advice?
There are clearly ethical dilemmas that pharmacists should consider when deciding whether or not it is appropriate to treat themselves, their family or friends. So what should pharmacists weigh up when faced with these situations?
Following the rules
Pharmacists who have trained as independent prescribers potentially face markedly different issues than those who have not. There may be a greater temptation for those who have the qualification to push the limits of what they should prescribe, and to whom, as Al Patel, owner of Lee Pharmacy in south-east London, can attest to.
Mr Patel is trained as a prescriber and acknowledges that it is sometimes “quite tempting just to take something off the shelf” when he is feeling unwell. But the guidance on self-prescribing for independent prescribers is clear-cut (available here), and Mr Patel stresses he would never actually take medication he had prescribed himself. Not only is it considered “unethical”, but it could result in fitness-to-practise issues, he warns.
The Royal Pharmaceutical Society (RPS) points to guidelines published by the Department of Health (DH) in 2006, which state that in most circumstances independent prescribers must never prescribe medication for themselves, close friends or family members.
However, there are exceptions to this rule. The guidance states that prescribers may administer medication to themselves or loved ones if there is no one else present who can legally prescribe, if it is a life-threatening situation, if medication could prevent a serious deterioration in health, or if the patient is in uncontrollable pain. Pharmacists must also be able to explain the “exceptional” circumstances that they believe justified their actions.
These guidelines are backed up by advice from the General Pharmaceutical Council (GPhC). Independent prescribers should “carefully” consider how appropriate it is to prescribe medication or provide clinical services to themselves or their family, because their ability to remain impartial could be negatively affected, the regulator says. It recommends pharmacists use their professional judgment “in each individual situation”, using GPhC standards to inform their decisions, and keep “appropriate records”.
In short, pharmacists should avoid using their prescribing skills on those close to them in anything other than extreme circumstances. Contractor and RPS board member Sid Dajani says he “wouldn’t dream” of doing so unless it was a “life or death” situation. He explains that the guidelines on self-prescribing were spelled out to him when he was still in training: “Basically, the line is that you don’t self-prescribe or prescribe for those nearest to you because it might be deemed unethical.”
4 key points independent prescribers must remember
1. Learn the guidance The Department of Health has issued guidance on self-prescribing. You should be familiar with it.
2. Know your limits When treating yourself or loved ones, you need to be sure that you are emotionally detached enough to make good clinical decisions.
3. Use your judgment In personal situations, independent prescribers can only prescribe if circumstances are exceptional, such as if somebody is in uncontrollable pain, in a life-or-death situation, or if there is no one else present who can legally prescribe the medication.
4. Understand the consequences Self-prescribing or prescribing for those close to you could land you in hot water if you cannot explain to the General Pharmaceutical Council why you considered the circumstances in which you took this action to be exceptional. Think before you act.
Lack of guidance
For independent prescribers, the clear cut-off point for acceptable self-treatment in most situations is when prescription medication is needed. But for most pharmacists – who can’t prescribe – there is little guidance on what level of self-treatment is appropriate.
Hertfordshire contractor Graham Phillips says he regularly uses his clinical knowledge to treat himself for minor conditions such as coughs and colds. “I’m not going to waste the GP’s time with my sore throat when all I need are a couple of paracetamol,” he says. But in any circumstance where he would advise a patient to seek another medical opinion, he would take the same course of action for himself, he says.
Naturally, pharmacists’ clinical knowledge can be a useful tool when seeking treatment from other healthcare providers. Mr Dajani points out that his diagnostic skills as an independent prescriber can come in handy when speaking to another clinician about his health. “I know what information they would need and [ensure it is] on-hand,” he says.
Helping friends and family
It’s one thing to treat yourself when feeling under the weather, but for many, treating friends and family is a different matter. Mr Phillips says he is “probably more cautious” when advising loved ones on their medical conditions. “You have an emotional relationship with them and it’s easy to confuse things,” he says. “If it’s a case of [treating] myself, the only person I’m damaging is me.”
Mr Dajani says he’s quite happy to help with queries from family members or friends about which healthcare provider is the most appropriate destination for their condition. He would also be comfortable to carry out services such as medicines use reviews (MURs) on those close to him, because he believes he can remain “factual” about their conditions without allowing emotions to cloud his judgment. “You can detach yourself and still be safe [to give advice],” he says.
An awkward situation
But just as it is sometimes tempting for pharmacists to bend the rules and treat themselves when they are ill, friends and family may also want to squeeze advice from you when the opportunity crops up.
Mr Patel says he often sees patients outside of work who take the opportunity to get his professional opinion for minor conditions: “I’ll bump into customers and they’ll say, ‘Oh hi, how are you? By the way, this is my wife. While you’re here, can I just quickly ask you [about] a couple of problems?’
“Once I went to Sainsbury’s, and for three hours I got stuck when I bumped into somebody I knew in every single aisle,” he recalls.
Pharmacists with an independent prescribing qualification could find that the boundary between being a friend and clinician is even more blurred. As a pharmacist with prescribing skills specialising in dermatology and asthma, Mr Patel is aware that he could be put in an “awkward situation” if friends or family members were to ask him to write them a private prescription for an inhaler.
“It’s something you would need to think very carefully about if you were to find yourself in that situation,” he says, stressing that he has never done it himself. “I’d probably say, ‘See your GP, they’re best at treating you’,” he adds.
With so much to consider when self-treating or treating those close to you, it could be argued that the issue begs a wider discussion from the profession about what is and isn’t appropriate. It’s a topic that may seem less pressing than other issues currently facing the sector, but one that Mr Phillips says should be on “the list of things to do” for community pharmacy.
Some pharmacists may be happy to take their own advice or to share their expertise with loved ones. Others may feel uncomfortable doing so. But crucially, they must know at what point their decision-making could become clouded by emotional considerations and personal relationships. Ultimately, each pharmacist must reach their own conclusion about where that point lies – or risk making a decision that could endanger friends, family or themselves.
The GP view
What can pharmacists learn about how other health professionals view self-treatment? A GP talks anonymously to C+D about their experiences
Is it common for doctors to prescribe medication for themselves, friends or family members?
It used to be common, especially for convenience and for minor, pragmatic or acute things, such prescribing antibiotics. But obviously prescribing sleeping pills and antidepressants was less widespread, because it was asking for trouble.
However, it’s much less [common] nowadays ,with a toughened General Medical Council stance [published in 2013]. I think the advent of regular appraisals and revalidation has had an effect too, as it has made GPs more aware of these issues and made them feel more scrutinised.
Is it something you would consider doing?
I wouldn’t now, no. But I have in the distant past [for things like] antibiotics for my son with tonsillitis and repeat asthma inhalers for me – purely for convenience.
I think the only times GPs would prescribe now for themselves or their family would be in an emergency when there was little other option, and then only antibiotics or other clear-cut acute medications, or non-contentious repeat prescriptions.
It is very unlikely that GPs would self-medicate anything heavy-duty nowadays, such as antidepressants or night sedation, given current guidance and the fact that [it would be] very hard to objectively treat yourself for this type of thing.
On the other hand, the arguments by those that do [self-prescribe] might include the poor provision of mental health services for GPs – something the government has only just acknowledged.
Where would you draw the line at self-treatment?
We want to hear your views, but please express them in the spirit of a constructive, professional debate. For more information about what this means, please click here to see our community principles and information
